I complied Seafood in the Circle City to showcase the best seafood restaurants in Indianapolis, as well as those that don’t necessarily focus on seafood, but still have some excellent offerings. So whether you’re a steak-lover, think burgers are the way to go, or always order the token chicken dish on the menu (sorry poultry fans) why not step out of your wheelhouse and order seafood? Your taste buds will thank you, and so will your heart.

And if you represent a restaurant not on this list, drop me a line. I’d love to come and visit and continue to grow this guide to the best seafood in Indianapolis. Because I know there are lots of fish in the sea|

Indianapolis Restaurants with Seafood (in alpha order)
Anthony’s Chophouse, Carmel
Broken English Taco Pub, Indianapolis Downtown (formerly)
Caplinger’s Fresh Catch, Multiple Locations
Chiba, Westfield
Convivio, Carmel
Hyde Park Prime Steakhouse, Indianapolis Downtown
Italian House on Park, Westfield
Mama Carolla’s, Indianapolis Broad Ripple
Main Street Poke, Carmel Arts District
Mitchell’s Fish Market, Carmel
Oceanaire Seafood Room, Indianapolis Downtown
Pad Thai, Carmel Arts District
PF Changs, Indianapolis Keystone
Prime 47, Carmel
Rail, Westfield
Ruth’s Chris, Multiple Locations
Salt on Mass, Indianapolis Downtown
Spoke and Steele, Indianapolis Downtown
Vida, Indianapolis Downtown

Kona Jacks
St. Elmo
Market District
Noah Grants
Harry and Izzy’s
Kona Grill
Tinker Street
Ricks Boatyard
Char Blue
Chef Oya’s The Trap
Kona Jacks
Northside Social
Public Greens
Bonefish Grill